The Hindu: Relentless killing of Shia Muslims in Pakistan

According to an estimate, more than 20,000 Shia Muslims have been killed in Pakistan in the last few decades at the hands of Deobandi militants (namely Sipah Sahaba and Taliban who are also killing Sunni Barelvis, Ahmadis and Christians).
(Ahlul Bayt News Agency) - Pakistan’s Shias are so regularly killed in targeted attacks that counting the numbers who were thus killed in 2012 is an uphill task. But just to give an idea, even before the start of the Muharram month, when anti-Shia violence is usually routinely anticipated and accepted as a given, the numbers killed had crossed 389 — the number of people the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan says died in sectarian violence in 2011. [According to an estimate, more than 20,000 Shia Muslims have been killed in Pakistan in the last few decades at the hands of Deobandi militants (namely Sipah Sahaba and Taliban who are also killing Sunni Barelvis, Ahmadis and Christians.)

This time, the Deobandi terrorists were emboldened enough to announce their intent. Ahead of Muharram, a number of Shias received text messages saying ‘Kill, Kill Shias.’ Sure enough, the self-appointed deciders of who is or is not a Muslim struck, killing 23 in two separate bomb blasts early on in the Muharram month.


Through the year, Deobandi terrorists of Sipah Sahaba and Taliban have been relentless in going after Shias; be it in Parachinar along the Pakistan-Afghanistan border, Gilgit-Baltistan, Quetta, Karachi or the garrison town of Rawalpindi. The clinical manner in which the terrorists have been going about their “mission” has been chilling, generating enough disquiet among the members of the community to take to the streets on December 8 outside the United Nations headquarters in New York protesting the “genocide in Pakistan.”

Of all Shias, the Shia Hazaras of Quetta are sitting ducks, their distinctive Mongloid features marking them out. At least 500 Shia Hazaras and 300 non-Hazara Shias have been killed in Quetta alone. They are pulled out of buses and shot down often enough to force many to leave the country. In all other Shia killings too — except the attacks on Muharram processions — Shias of all ethnic backgrounds are identified by the killers from among large groups of people, by the self-flagellation scars acquired by Shia men during the Muharram mourning rituals.

The video footage of one such attack on the Karakoram Highway (Gilgit Baltistan province) earlier this year shows a convoy of buses being stopped by gun-toting terrorists. Unhurriedly, the terrorists — dressed in Army fatigues — ask the passengers to furnish their national identity cards to single out those with Shia names.

The grainy video does not clearly show this but some accounts of the attack claim the passengers were made to recite a particular prayer which Shias say differently. Thereafter, the ‘kameez’ (shirts) of the men were lifted to check for self-flagellation marks. Their Shia identity established, they were lined up and killed amid chants of “kafir, kafir; Shia kafir” (infidels, infidels; Shia are infidels). In this particular attack, three Sunni men were also killed for trying to defend the Shias.

More chilling than the actual violence is the general acceptance of such incidents. Apart from the momentary media coverage, perfunctory editorials and outpouring of angst on various social media platforms when an incident like this happens, not much national debate ever takes place over Shia killings. But it may not help very much either, going by the zero difference that the national debate over Malala’s shooting has made.

Unlike other persecuted communities, the Shias — who constitute about 20 per cent of the population — are not down and out socially or politically. “The President, Chairman of Senate and National Assembly Speaker — three constitutional office-holders in the country — are Shias but they seldom speak up for the community for fear of losing political clout or support of non-Shias. Similar apathy exists in the media [where many honchos are Shias]. Many of my colleagues do not speak about sectarian issues for fear of being branded fundamentalists/extremists,” rues Baqir Sajjad Syed of Dawnnewspaper.

According to Islamic Research Institute Director-General Khalid Masud, Shias have traditionally been leading contributors to the intellectual discourse among the subcontinent’s Muslims. Yet, a recent Pew Research Centre study showed that 50 per cent of Pakistanis do not accept Shias as Muslims. Sunni Barelvi (Sufi) Muslims are not involved in acts of violence against Shias; in almost all instance of Shia genocide, a Deobandi militant is involved.

Though Shia-Sunni differences are not new to the subcontinent, Pakistan’s penchant for allowing geo-politics to be played out in its backyard has exacerbated the tensions; particularly since the Iranian Revolution and the Soviet occupation of Afghanistan that quickly followed.


While the Iranian Revolution, according to historian Tahir Kamran, seemingly “emboldened” Pakistan’s Shias who “abandoned the Shia tradition of political quietism,” the Afghan jihad against the Soviets had the Saudis bankroll the then military ruler Zia-ul Haq’s Islamisation project which encouraged the “Sunnification of Pakistan.” More than Sunnification, it was Deobandi-Wahhabification of Pakistan which was equally resisted by Sunni Barelvis and Shias.

“Not only ‘awakened’ but ‘emboldened’ in the wake of the Revolution’s success in Iran, the Shia were public and vociferous in putting forward demands for ‘rights and representation’, trusting in Khomeini’s support, which he quite lavishly extended to them. Former Foreign Minister of Pakistan Agha Shahi revealed: ‘Khomeni once sent a message to Zia-ul Haq, telling him that if he mistreated the Shia, he [Khomeni] would do to him what he had done to the Shah’,” Mr. Kamran wrote in an essay in the publication Sectarian Militancy in Pakistan.

The Saudi-backed effort to turn Pakistan into not just a Sunni country but a Deobandi Sunni stream — that, too, of the puritanical Wahabbi-Salafi order — clashed directly with this Shia assertiveness in Pakistan. An early point of clash arose when Zia made it compulsory for all Muslims to pay zakat (a tax to support charity) to the state.

“Shia jurisprudence regards this as a personal matter … and a very large number of Shias organised to demand that they be excluded … This Shia movement was given some support by Iran … While the Shias won that round …, a line had been drawn that has continued to become darker and bloodier with time,” wrote Pakistani-American writer Omar Ali in an article on ‘Shias and their future in Pakistan.’


It is important to note that Shia genocide in Pakistan at the hands of Saudi-paid ISI-sponsored excommunicator Deobandi militants cannot be treated as an outcome of Saudi-Iran proxy war because excommunicator Deobandi militants are also killing a large number of Sunni Sufi Muslims, Ahamdiyya Muslims and Christians. The Sunni-Shia sectarianism and Saudi-Iran proxy war discourse offers a false neutral and equal impression of the nature of violence which remains generally uni-directional.

A native of Jhang — the hub of anti-Shia terror networks like Deobandi group Sipah-e-Sahaba (SSP) and its breakaway Lashkar-e-Jhangvi (LeJ) — Prof. Masud maintains that the anti-Shia rhetoric began much earlier as he recalls hate literature against Shias being circulated from the 1950s in this central Punjab district. So the ground was fertile for Saudi-backed ‘Sunnification’ and this made Shias launch their own militant outfit, clearly sharpening the divide.

Technically banned, the Deobandis of SSP and the LeJ have a free run with the former functioning under the new name, Ahle Sunnat Wal Jamaat (ASWJ). The SSP — which has contested elections — has a vote bank and the ASWJ claimed that the Pakistan Muslim League (Nawaz) won the recent by-elections in Punjab with its help. Such alliances debilitate political parties’ ability to adopt zero tolerance towards terrorism.

All this notwithstanding, the anti-Shia rhetoric has till date not percolated into the curriculum Islamised under Zia. “In fact, many in the Pakistani middle class still have no clear idea of where the anti-Shia polemic is coming from. It was not part of our education. While Shias were a minority sect, their version of Karbala and the martyrdom of Husain was accepted …,’’ writes Mr. Ali adding that Saudi Wahhabis have a well-developed anti-Shia polemic that brands Shias as heretics.

While SSP and Co want Shias to be declared ‘non-Muslims’ like the Ahmadis, Dr. Masud maintains this is unlikely as the Shia community is much larger than the Ahmadis. Ironically, a few Shia parliamentarians had supported the law against Ahmadis, however, majority of Shia clerics and ordinary public were not a part of anti-Ahmadi movement in Pakistan, and not a single act of anti-Ahmadi violence is attributed to Shias.

Source: Adapted with minor editing from The Hindu to remove some minor omissions and misstatements.

Related News:

Saudi-Backed Terrorists Killed 2 More Shia Muslims 18.12.2012
Do the Pakistani Shiites Met Their Demands After 40 Hours Sit-In? / 5 More Shot Killed 17.12.2012
Shia Genocide Continues: Saudi-Backed Wahhabis Martyr 7 Shiite in Pakistan15.12.2012
Custodian of Mosque and His Nephew Martyred in Karachi 13.12.20102

Saudi-Backed Terrorists Murdered Two More Shia Muslims 12.12.2012
Shia Genocide Continues in Pakistan: Shia Police Officer 'Ali Abbas Naqvi' and 'Hajan Ali' Martyred in Karachi
Pakistan: Injured of Ashura procession blast Zameer Shah martyred 9.12.2012
4 More Pakistani Shiite Muslims Victimized by the State Terrorism 8.12.2012

Shia Man 'Tanveer Bangash' Martyred in Karachi 6.12.2012
Pakistan: Saudi-Backed Wahhabi Terrorists Martyr Two Shia Men 5.12.2012
Saudi-Backed Wahhabi Terrorists Kill a Shia Cleric and His 4-Year-Old Daughter in Pakistan 4.12.2012
Pakistani Shia 'Mohammed Daraz' Martyred 2.12.2012
80 Pakistani Shia Martyred in November 2012
6 Pakistani Shia Muslims Martyred by Saudi/US-Backed Terrorists + Pics 1.12.2012
Wahhabi Terrorists Martyr 2 Pakistani Shia Muslims 29.11.2012
Two More Pakistani Shia Martyred in Sindh Province 27.11.2012
Pakistan: Blast Near Ashura Procession in DI Khan Kills Five Shia Mourners 26.11.2012
Bomb attack kills 7 Shia Muslims in Pakistan  24.11.2012

Terrorists' Attack Leaves 16 Shia Martyred in Pakistan 22.11.2012
Pakistan: Shia Muslim 'Muhammad Arif' Martyrs in Karachi 21.11.2012
2 Martyred, Many Injured in Karachi Blast Near at Shiite Mosque 19.11.2012
Pakistan: Two Shiite Muslims Including a 18-Year-Old Boy Victims of State Terrorism in Karachi  14.11.2012
Pakistan: Terrorists Open Fire at Vegetable Shop, 4 Shiite Muslims Martyred, 1 Wounded 13.11.2012
Pakistan: 4 Shiite Muslims Including a Father and His Two Sons Martyred in Karachi 12.11.2012
Shia Genocide Continues in Pakistan, 4 Shia Martyred by State Terrorism  11.11.2012
Wahhabi Terrorists Martyr 3 More Shia Muslims in Pakistan 10.11.2012
Nine More Shia Muslims Martyred by Sipah-e-Sahaba Terrorists in Pakistan 8.11.2012
Pakistan: 9 Shia Muslims Victimized by the State Terrorism 6.11.2012
Pakistani Shia Leader 'Allama Aftab Haider Jafri Martyred in Karachi 6.11.2012
One Shia Muslim martyred, 2 injured, 1 missing in Taliban terrorists attack in Parachinar 5.11.2012
Pakistan: A Shia Muslim Murdered in Front of His Mother and Sister in Quetta 5.11.2012
Two Shia Muslims Embraced Martyrdom in Karachi 4.11.2012
Pakistan: Shiite Muslim 'Syed Mehmood Ali' Embraced Martyrdom in Karachi 29.10.2012
Pakistan: 2 Shia Youths Martyred, 6 Injured in D.I.Khan 29.10.2012
Pakistan: Shia police official martyred in a targeted attack of terrorists in Gilgit 27.10.2012
Pakistan: Shiite teenager 'Ali Abbas' spent 4 years in ICU martyred in Peshawar 27.10.2012
Pakistan: Extremists Open Fire Killing Shiite Ashiq Hussain in Karachi 25.10.2012
Karachi: Injured Shiite dies of injuries 24.10.2012
Pakistan: Four Shia Muslims seriously injured in a murderous attack by takfiri terrorists 23.10.2012
Pakistani Shia Journalist Martyred in a Targeted Attack by Takfiri Terrorists 23.10.2012


عزای حسینی در عالم
Imam Khamenei demands immediate end to domestic wars in Islamic countries in his Hajj 2017 message
پیام امام خامنه ای به مسلمانان جهان به مناسبت حج 2016
We are All Zakzaky